Marketing

08 December 2008

A Wiki of Social Media Marketing Examples

Over the weekend, I created a framework to port A List of Social Media Marketing Examples into a wiki.  I also invited the 166 people who've left comments on that post to become the initial collaborators in the new effort. (At least I tried to...Google Sites seems to have had a delivery problem. If you think you should have a login, try your existing email address - it may already be setup.)

Soon after inception, several people asked about turning the list into a wiki, which is a natural container for this type of information.  However, I delayed doing this immediately for many reasons.

One of the benefits of doing so manifests in the framework, which allows users to sort information by different categories.  In an early experiment, I had created an alphabetical directory by company name, with 26 pages.  Continuing with that approach would've meant replicating efforts to relist examples by channel, industry, or geography.

Let me say thanks again to everyone who's contributed to help create

A Wiki of Social Media Marketing Examples

I'm looking forward to collaborating on this new community resource with you.

03 December 2008

Slicing and Dicing A List of Social Media Marketing Examples

Since starting a list of social media marketing examples, I've seen some great work to frame content for specific uses:

By technology/media type

By country

  • Australia: former colleague Steven Noble has bookmarked many examples
  • Canada: David Jones has set up a wiki
  • Germany:  Benedikt Köhler has blogged a list
  • Malaysia:  A table at GreyReview
  • United Kingdom:  John Welsh has blogged a list

By industry

  • Haven't seen any yet...
If you are maintaining or know of a segmented list, please let me know and I'll link to you here.

12 November 2008

Ego Trap: Social Media Ranking Tools

It seems like a new ego trap gets sprung every month.  This time, it's social media ranking tools.

What's an ego trap? In a nutshell, social technologies use game mechanics to get users hooked on participation.  People often get addicted to ego-stroking system feedback, until they can temper their usage (addiction?) in terms of utility vs. serendipity.  Self-promotion lies at the root of ego traps.

I don't think ego traps are inherently "bad."  However, I believe that individuals should be fully aware of the implications when participating - particularly what they're trying to accomplish and why.  Honesty with one's own ego is the key.

Some people are panicking after submitting their Twitter username and password to a site called Twitterank, which will "determine how worthy of a person you are in Twitterverse," while potentially stealing your password in the process.  Clearly an ego trap in action.  Why?

  • There's no practical use of the service except for stroking one's ego. 
[Okay, I know the other posts had longer lists, but this one is just too obvious.]

Similar social media ranking tools include egoSurf, Twitter Grader, twInfluence, and [the now defunct] TweeterBoard.

Ranking tools are great when they're used for fun.  Be smart and don't give out your password to random sites.

BTW if you want to see if your favorite Tweeter got caught in the Twitterank ego trap, visit http://new.twitterank.com/?u=[username]

Previously:

03 November 2008

What goes up must come down

Influence: like Plinko?

I've typically thought of influence tactics as uni-directional, in a downward direction.  I imagine that the traditional approach of getting a message widely disseminated consists of targeting a beacon and letting your message bounce down a pyramid of nodes, like Plinko.

A "good" beacon exhibits wide reach, in the media sense.  Traditional media fit the bill quite nicely here.  The better the beacon, the more widely your message will travel.  The more beacons you seed, the more pyramids you'll sow.

Tom O'Brien's comment on influence has got me thinking about how beacons operate in social media.  They get used in two ways:

  • Some programs target influencers as "quality beacons" that disperse messages effectively to a niche.
  • Other programs target influencers in "beacon quantity," reaching out to as many nodes as possible within budget - think mommy networks, BzzAgent.

No doubt, social media has democratized influence and both of these approaches work.

What if we turn the board upside-down?

But I wonder if there's another more surgical approach to outreach that doesn't assume a uni-directional downward message dispersion.  What happens when you connect to beacons that will transmit upwards instead?  Doesn't it follow that what goes up, must come down?

For example, I was recently emailed by an author who said that a certain trade publication wouldn't review a new book.  I know the book has been sent out and been reviewed by some well-read bloggers, i.e. quality beacons.  But wouldn't this have been more effective by targeting "influencers" who would be able to connect directly with traditional media?  I know journalists participate in pyramids like everyone else - but I'm pretty sure no one wants to write a story two weeks after it's been kicked around in the blogosphere.

Maybe this is what professionals already do...

Maybe this is just PR 101 and I don't know it.  I've never had any formal outreach training, which you can probably tell...so if I've offended the PR professionals who read this blog, I apologize - please enlighten me!

From the outside, it seems like today's blogger outreach should be happening at step two, preceded by a step one of more precise and surgical targeting of upward-facing influencers - and rarely, if ever make a noise within the echo chamber, let alone in public.

31 October 2008

Influencer, persuade thyself.

I've been reading the reactions to Pepsi's recent influencer outreach program, PR for The Pepsi Cooler.  Have been thinking about it in the perspective of other outreach campaigns, like Nikon, Vista, HP.

Seems like the lesson here - whether intentional or not - is "influencer, persuade thyself."  You don't make a meaningful dent in a $39 billion business by sending some aluminum out to 25 well-networked people.  What you do achieve is a discussion that starts to bounce around the echo chamber.  That's not necessarily a bad thing.

"There is only one thing in life worse than being talked about, and that is not being talked about." - Oscar Wilde


So what's NOT being talked about here?  Coca-Cola.  RC Cola.  Jones.  Red Bull.  Et al.

Look at this spike in Google search traffic for "pepsi new logo" since the first delivery date.  You think the program's working?

27 October 2008

Free marketing advice and education


Chipotle Boortio, 10/31.

Times are tough, for sure - but that hasn't reduced the number of gratis opportunities available to learn and network for free.  I've noticed more than a few events happening this week, offering free advice and education.  Thought I'd pass them along, in case you're interested.

If you have anything to add to the list, please comment below and I'll include above.

15 October 2008

Ego Trap: Influencer Lists

I've been thinking about how ego traps operate in social media - which could also be called hero marketing (credit Seth Godin for suggesting the term).  Social media focuses on individuals.  Self-promotion lies at the root of ego traps, usually inclusive of helping and promoting others.

I don't think ego traps are inherently "bad."  However, I believe that individuals should be fully aware of the implications when participating in a hero marketing scheme - particularly what they're trying to accomplish and why.  Honesty with one's own ego is the key.

There's some chatter going on about "50 of the most powerful and influential women in social media."

Influencer lists are ego traps in action.  Why?

  • The list host seeks credibility as an authority, in order to win more business.
  • Those included on the list legitimize the host by linking back to the list.
  • Those left off the list (and/or their friends) legitimize the list by linking to it.

(To Ron Hudson's credit, he comments on the digg story, "...digg this story so that they are discovered by more people. Keep in mind, you will also be contributing to my own popularity as well. With that in mind, digg or digg not.")  Other influencer lists include people on Twitter, marketing bloggers, or the Silicon Alley 100.

Influencer lists are great for discovering new voices and recognizing well-done work.  Let's just be aware of and honest about what everyone seeks in the process.

Previously - Ego Trap: Industry Awards

13 October 2008

Defining Social Media Marketing

I don't like the Wikipedia definition of social media marketing, because it focuses too much on search and does not touch on corporate marketing or integration.  So let's try a new definition by thinking through the phrase "social media marketing," backwards:

  • Marketing. A business function which exists to drive sales, by matching (sometimes generating) consumer need to company solutions, i.e. promotion that makes consumers aware of features and benefits, a product that fulfills a purpose, a price that the consumer is willing to pay, and a place where the solution can be obtained.
  • Media. The plural of medium, a container or channel used to deliver content to individuals.
  • Social. More accurately, socializing - interaction between individuals.  Call and response, idea and feedback.

Producing a definition of social media marketing:

"Interaction between individuals in [digital] delivery channels, exchanging content related to consumer needs and company solutions."

That's theory.  In practice, things start to break down and few marketers are operate in the conversational nirvana promised by social media evangelists.  Why?

  • Media + Marketing. Inefficient traditional marketing, one-way delivery of sales messages.
  • Social + Marketing. Unscalable marketing programs, limited by employee participation (when allowed) and uncontrollable community evangelism.
  • Social + Media. Breaks when marketing content comes into play. Individuals interact by phone too, but dislike being dialed by telemarketers.

So social media marketing can be more precisely defined as:

"Interaction between a company and individual via [digital] delivery channels, intended to share commercial content that will lead to a sale and/or be passed along to others."

What am I missing here?  This sounds pretty much like traditional marketing to me.

03 October 2008

234 Social Media Marketing Examples


234 examples, visualized. Created using http://wordle.net/

A month ago, I published a list of social media marketing examples.  At the time, the list started with 131 brands that were involved in social media to some extent.  (Sometimes not by their own choice.)

A month later, the list has added over 100 new brands due to the contributions of 81 community members.

Some interesting things happened along the way.  Dion Hincliffe from Social Computing Magazine requested permission to republish the list, no problem.  Almost 200 other bloggers have found the list helpful and I hope you do as well.  Unfortunately, I also stumbled across a few cases of plagiarism - two that were coincidentally blamed on "assistants" blogging whose work had not been checked.  (Really?  Maybe I need to get a blogging assistant, too.  But I'll be sure to equip that person with a copy of the MLA.)

As my way of saying thanks, here's a search engine shout-out to give credit where credit is due to everyone who has contributed to the list (either directly or through prior art):

Jeremiah Owyang, Mashable, Forrester, Mack Collier, Social Brand Index, Gavin Heaton, Philippe Deltenre, zeroinfluencer, Bruce Eric Anderson, Nick Ayres, Jeff Glasson, Luke, Mike, Robin Seidner, Tom Shea, Ed Nicholson, Stefan Halley, Tom Hoehn, Debbie Weil,  Marta Kagan, Paull Young, Kevin, Paul Fabretti, Nick Huhn, dominic, Michael Pranikoff, Kyle Flaherty, Ed Terpenning, Chi-chi Ekweozor, Lisa, David Bressler, C.B. Whittemore, Torley, David Jones, Keith De La Rue, Sean Lew, Tom Cummings, Donna Tocci, Adam Singer, Yianni Garcia, Matt Cronin, Stephen Manning, Jim Dietzel, Clayton, Mike, Kira Wampler, Woody Meachum, Lee Aase, Toby Bloomberg, Adam Denison, Colleen Gatlin, Davezilla, Gina, Marcos Fargas, Marianne Richmond, Kevin Barenblat, Dan Entin, Bruce Ertmann, Sean Moffitt, Elana Bowman, Dan, Andrew, James O'Connor, Herve Kabla, Sachin Agarwal, Lou Cuming, Danny Urguia, Kathrin Lohmann, Rafa, John Galpin, Ken Kaplan, Kathy Mandelstein, BJ Cook, John Welsh, Nils Koenig, James Finnen, Miko, Yvonne DiVita, Juny Lee, Massimo Cavazzini, and Gunther Lie.

But seriously...234.  Do you think that's it?

21 September 2008

Ego Trap: Industry Awards

I've been thinking about how ego traps operate in social media - which could also be called hero marketing (credit Seth Godin for suggesting the term).  Essentially, social media focuses on individuals and ego traps help promote individuals, not necessarily at the expense of helping/promoting others.

I don't think ego traps are inherently "bad."  However, I believe that individuals should be fully aware of the implications when participating in a hero marketing scheme - particularly what they're trying to accomplish and why.  Honesty with one's own ego is the key.  (Or is it the id that's really the problem?)

Jeremiah has started a list of social media marketing awards.  Self-submitted industry award competitions are ego traps in action.  Why?

  • Agencies seek credit for their work, so they can win more clients.
  • Clients seek recognition for success, so they can ask for bigger budgets and salaries.
  • Judges seek credit as subject matter experts, so they can get more business.
  • Award hosts seek credibility as industry authorities, so they can get more business.

Award competitions work well when executed properly (i.e. focused topic, large sample of competition, critical judgment process), because they can be a quintuple-win situation for the participants: clients, agencies, judges, hosts, and observers.  Let's just be aware of and honest about what everyone seeks in the process.

10 September 2008

Critical observations of 204 social media marketing examples

Last week, I shared a list of about 120 companies using and/or being used by social media marketing.  Less than a week later, that list has almost doubled solely based on community contributions.  Thank you for sharing.

The list seems big enough to support some analysis.  What do you think about these three major criticisms?

1. Big companies are lagging indicators.

  • Although C.B. notes: "It's amazing to realize how many organizations now have a presence [when they didn't not very long ago] and also across several different platforms."
  • Alfonso responds: "Keep your eye on the big boys to get an idea of what the me-too crowd does. No doubt they do it bigger and louder, but they have to: they're playing catch-up."
  • Robert agrees: "I think we all have the tendency to gravitate to the household names to illustrate social media examples, but these companies often are laggards."

2. Are these examples really social?

  • Dan points out: "There's a difference between participating in social media and marketing via social media."
  • Tony takes this further: "Some of these examples feel a little more like social network digital advertising rather than social media."

3. Stuff is missing.

  • Tim asks: "Where are the 'internal' employee/partner examples?"
  • Philipp asks: "Are there more examples from Europe or the German speaking regions?"
  • Antje says: "Next list should be smaller companies without huge budgets."

Your thoughts, reactions, and observations are appreciated.

  • Should we really be watching SMBs instead?
  • Is this conversation or lecturing?
  • Why are we seeing these gaps?

08 September 2008

Graphic analysis of 204 social media marketing examples

Last week, I shared a list of about 120 companies using and/or being used by social media marketing.  Less than a week later, that list has almost doubled solely based on community contributions.  Thank you for sharing.

The list seems big enough to support some analysis.  What do you think about this graphic?

202examples

(You can create your own at wordle.net.)

Thoughts?

03 September 2008

A List of Social Media Marketing Examples

I've been thinking about how social media works.  For example, applying game mechanics to understand participation, thinking about users vs. customers, and deconstructing ego traps in PR campaigns.  This analysis makes me wonder if social media marketing matters and if so, does it scale.

I thought you might benefit from some of my background research on these topics.  And I'd appreciate your help in curating this list by providing more details and submitting additional cases.

[update 10.17.08] Thanks for your input and additions - the list has more than doubled from community contributions.  For easier storing and sharing, you can stumble, bookmark, or digg this page.

[update 10.29.08] For updates, you can subscribe to this page's comments feed or Twitter hashtag search for #smmlist.  The page also has a shortened URL: http://bit.ly/smmlist.

[update 12.08.08] I've set up a framework for these examples in a wiki.  Please contribute any new examples (and port your old ones) into A Wiki of Social Media Marketing Examples.

>> Last update: 23 November 2008
>> Total brands: 324

Examples of companies using and being used by social media marketing: